Starts:

Thursday, September 22nd
4:30pm-6:00pm EDT

Category:

Topical Workshop

Tracks:

Placebo

Room

717 B

Basic and Clinical Research Exploring Acupuncture Therapy for Pain

Acupuncture in an ancient medical technique originated in China. By inserting thin needles into body at specific anatomical locations, improvements in a range of symptoms, especially painful conditions, have been reported empirically and by many meta-analyses of clinical trials. However, the therapeutic values of acupuncture for pain management are fraught with controversy, largely due to difficulty to dissociate specific effects of acupuncture needling techniques from non-specific therapeutic effects such as placebo effects and social interaction as well as ambiguity in acupuncture’s effects on clinical outcomes and physiological mechanisms. As the United States is combating an opioid crisis and the underlying challenges of pain management, acupuncture has emerged as a prominent complementary solution. Better understanding of how and whether acupuncture works for pain relief is now critical as we consider the possibility of its broader usage for pain management. This session will bring four speakers, Dr. Wen G. Chen from NCCIH/NIH, Dr. Vitaly Napadow from Harvard Medical School, Dr. Karen Sherman from the Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute, and Dr. Claudia Witt from the University of Zurich, to present and discuss the current scientific research and implementation challenges for acupuncture and pain.

Presentations

Time
4:30pm EDT6:00pm EDT

Basic, Mechanistic, and Clinical Research Exploring Acupuncture Therapy for Pain: an NIH perspective

Tracks: Placebo
Categories: Topical Workshop
Presented By: Dr. Wen G. Chen

Dr. Chen will introduce the panel and speakers, provide an overview and international scope of acupuncture research, highlight some recent advances in basic, mechanistic, and clinical acupuncture and pain research, and moderate the session. Acupuncture in an ancient medical technique originated in China. By inserting thin needles into body at specific anatomical locations, improvements in a range of symptoms, especially painful conditions, have been reported empirically and by many meta-analyses of clinical trials.  However, the therapeutic values of acupuncture for pain management are fraught with controversy, largely due to difficulty to dissociate specific effects of acupuncture needling techniques from non-specific therapeutic effects such as placebo effects and social interaction as well as ambiguity in acupuncture’s effects on clinical outcomes and physiological mechanisms.  As the United States is combating an opioid crisis and the underlying challenges of pain management, acupuncture has emerged as a prominent complementary solution.  Better understanding of how and whether acupuncture works for pain relief is now critical as we consider the possibility of its broader usage for pain management. Recent advances on basic mechanisms by which acupuncture may exert its therapeutic effects, including work by Dr. Qiufu Ma funded by NCCIH, will be highlighted.

4:30pm EDT6:00pm EDT

Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness of Acupuncture

Tracks: Placebo
Categories: Topical Workshop
Presented By: Prof. Claudia M. Witt

For decision makers in healthcare the effectiveness of acupuncture is one relevant aspect. In an NIH-funded patient-level data meta-analyses it was found that acupuncture for back and neck pain, shoulder pain, osteoarthritis, and headache and migraine had a statistically significant and clinically relevant effect when compared to non-acupuncture controls. Result as well as confounding and effect moderating factors will be critically discussed. In times of limited resources for health care, economic analyses are a useful tool to provide information that can support economically reasonable decisions. Over the last 15 years several cost-effectiveness on acupuncture for chronic pain were published and summarized the systematic reviews, showing that the provision of acupuncture could be cost effective.

Key insights: The workshop participants will get insights into the critical reflected interpretation of the available effectiveness and cost-effectiveness data on acupuncture for chronic pain. They will gain knowledge about factors contributing to the size of the acupuncture effect. Furthermore, they will learn about basic methodological aspects of pragmatic trials and cost-effectiveness analyses and their advantages and limitations.

4:30pm EDT6:00pm EDT

Neuroimaging Somatosensory and Psychosocial Mechanisms Underlying Acupuncture

Tracks: Placebo
Categories: Topical Workshop
Presented By: Prof. Vitaly Napadow

Acupuncture consists of several components, including 1) ritual with palpation, diagnosis, and 2) somatosensory stimulation. Our recent study of acupuncture in treating carpal tunnel syndrome found that while verum and sham acupuncture interventions reduced symptom severity, verum acupuncture was superior to sham in producing improvements in neurophysiological outcomes, both locally to the wrist and in the brain. Specifically, acupuncture may improve median nerve function at the wrist due to neuroplasticity in primary somatosensory cortex following therapy. Additionally, the patient-clinician relationship and therapeutic alliance can significantly influence response to therapy. We completed fMRI hyperscanning in patient-clinician dyads who interacted via video transfer during clinician-initiated electroacupuncture treatment of evoked pain in fibromyalgia patients. Greater therapeutic alliance was noted for dyads following clinical interaction. Further, patients’ and clinicians’ brain response demonstrated consistent shared activation of social mirroring/theory-of-mind circuitry (e.g. Temporoparietal Junction, TPJ). Dyad-based analyses suggested that these nodes showed extensive dynamic coupling with the partners’ brain activity, but only in dyads who had established a clinical relationship prior to interaction. Patient-clinician mirroring in facial expressions was associated with greater therapeutic alliance and analgesia. Thus, patient-clinician coupling of brain activity in theory-of-mind/social mirroring circuitry supports therapeutic alliance and psychosocially-facilitated analgesia during clinical interaction.

Presenters

Prof. Claudia M. Witt

Director
University Hospital Zurich

Dr. Wen G. Chen

Chief, Basic and Mechanistic Research Branch
NIH

Prof. Vitaly Napadow

Professor
Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital, Harvard Medical School